Energy News  
Former dairy boss tried over China tainted milk scandal

Tian Wenhua, Sanlu Group Co.'s former board chairwoman and general manager, is taken by bailiffs into a court in Shijiazhuang, north China's Hebei Province, on Wednesday, Dec. 31, 2008. (AP Photo/Xinhua, Ding Lixin)

Tainted products: major scares involving China
The 'Made-in-China' brand has been tarnished repeatedly in recent years as Chinese consumer goods and food have been recalled around the world after being found to be unsafe.

Here is a list of the key cases and some of the Chinese government responses:

  • 2006-2007 - The cancer-causing red dye Sudan IV is found in a series of products in China ranging from cosmetics to poultry and chilli powder, despite being banned in the country.
  • March 2007: Pet food in North America and elsewhere around the world is recalled after animals start dying in large numbers. The tainted ingredients turn out to be wheat and rice derivatives from China, to which the chemical melamine -- normally used to make plastic -- had been added to give the appearance of higher protein content.
  • June 2007: Countries in several parts of the world recall Chinese-made toothpaste that is found to contain a chemical used in antifreeze for vehicles. China bans it after reports that dozens may have died in Latin America from ingesting it as an ingredient in medicine.
  • June 2007 - Importers of Chinese toys to the United States issue recalls after some of these are found to be coated with toxic lead paint. Similar products are later banned in several countries.
  • June 2007 - The US National Highway Traffic Safety Administration recalls 450,000 tyres made by leading manufacturer Hangzhou Zhongce Rubber Co. The company denies that its tyres are defective.
  • August 2007: Mattel recalls over 18 million Chinese-made toys over design faults and because some were coated with lead paint, although the US toy company takes responsibility for most of the problems and apologises.
  • January 2008: At least 10 consumers in Japan fall ill after eating Chinese-made dumplings, causing a major scare. Chinese officials deny that the contamination originated in their country.
  • September 2008: Countries around the world recall or ban Chinese dairy products after melamine is found in milk. At least six infants were known to have died, and 294,000 fell ill after ingesting the tainted milk.
  • October 2008: The tainted milk scandal widens when melamine is found in eggs made by a Chinese company, which leads to confirmation the chemical had been added to animal feed.
  • December 2008: China bans the use of 17 substances -- some commonly used as disinfectants or insecticides -- as food additives as part of a four-month safety campaign launched following the tainted milk scandal. Four who were indicted, from left, Tian Wenhua, Wang Yuliang, Hang Zhiqi and Wu Jusheng stand on trial in Shijiazhuang, north China's Hebei Province, on Wednesday, Dec. 31, 2008. (AP Photo/Xinhua, Ding Lixin) A business administration officer looks at a pile of melamine-tainted Sanlu products, including baby formula, in Wuhan in central China's Hubei province Monday, Nov. 17, 2008. (AP Photo) Tian Wenhua, Sanlu Group Co.'s former board chairwoman and general manager, stands on trial on the court, in Shijiazhuang, north China's Hebei Province, on Wednesday, Dec. 31, 2008. Xinhua photo by Ding Lixin.
  • by Staff Writers
    Shijiazhuang, China (AFP) Jan 1, 2009
    The former boss of the dairy firm at the heart of China's tainted milk scandal stood trial here Wednesday over a trail of death and sickness that pushed Chinese products off shelves worldwide.

    A small but vocal group of protesters gathered outside the court in this northern Chinese city, calling for justice after milk laced with an industrial chemical killed six babies and left 294,000 with kidney and urinary problems.

    "They should execute them all," shouted Hua Lian, a 45-year-old woman who described herself as a milk consumer, as roughly half-a-dozen relatives of sick children held up signs calling for justice.

    "They have to deal with these people harshly. Otherwise people will never learn."

    But lawyers monitoring the case for the families said the legal process had been flawed and that there was little chance of justice for the victims.

    The former head of the Sanlu Group, Tian Wenhua, and three colleagues were put on trial on charges of producing and selling defective products, which lawyers said would mean a maximum punishment of life in prison.

    The charges were weaker than lawyers for victims' families had initially expected, extinguishing the possibility that the four would face the death penalty.

    Tian's lawyer, Liu Xinwei, told AFP during an afternoon recess that Tian had not yet entered a plea.

    The official Xinhua news agency said the trial ended without an immediate verdict just after 10:00 pm (1400 GMT). The report said the verdict "will be announced at an unspecified future date" without giving further details.

    Sanlu was the first and biggest dairy producer found to have this year sold milk laced with melamine, a chemical used to make plastics which was mixed into watered-down milk to give the appearance of higher levels of protein.

    In all, 22 Chinese dairy firms were found to have sold tainted milk, and the government last week ordered them to pay 160 million dollars in compensation to the families of babies that died or fell ill.

    However the families and their lawyers criticised the sum as woefully inadequate, with some parents set to only receive about 300 dollars.

    "I'm a farmer. I don't have money to pay for the treatment. My son is still sick and he's not been able to get treatment," said one man who demonstrated outside the court before police pushed them away.

    The protesting relatives held up sheets of paper that read: "The victims have a right to participate in judicial proceedings."

    This reflected an apparently widespread complaint from the victims' relatives that they had not been allowed to tell the courts their version of events, and that authorities had rejected civil compensation lawsuits.

    "We asked to participate in the trial, in the prosecution. We felt that we had a right to participate as we represent the victims," said Xu Zhiyong, a lawyer working for a group of people seeking to sue Sanlu and other milk firms.

    "But the court refused to allow us. They didn't want the testimony of the people we represent. We think the court has violated legal procedures."

    Foreign press were not allowed inside the Shijiazhuang court, but Chinese state-run television and news services were let in to publicise the case.

    In China, trials are often held behind closed doors and last just one day.

    China's careful efforts to publicise the trials appeared to reflect the government's intent to show domestic and international audiences it was taking the issue seriously.

    The milk scandal became a global problem after it emerged some of the tainted products had been exported, leading to recalls of Chinese dairy foods around the world.

    It was just the latest in a spate of Chinese made products to have been recalled from overseas in recent years due to safety concerns, with other problem products including toys covered with lead paint and deadly pet food.

    The four Sanlu executives are the highest profile figures to be hauled before the courts over the scandal, after 17 people mostly accused of being middlemen went on trial in recent days.

    Those verdicts have yet to be announced but some of the defendants could face the death penalty.

    Share This Article With Planet Earth
    del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
    YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



    Related Links
    Farming Today - Suppliers and Technology



    Memory Foam Mattress Review
    Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
    XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


    Two more stand trial in China milk scandal
    Beijing (AFP) Dec 30, 2008
    Two more suspects in China's tainted milk scandal went on trial Tuesday, bringing to 17 the number who have faced court in high-profile proceedings over the nation's worst food safety case in years.







  • Analysis: 2008 Caspian energy production
  • Myanmar signs gas deal with SKorea, India, China: state media
  • Dominion And Shell Complete NedPower Mount Storm Wind Project
  • November OPEC Oil Output Fell To 31.38 Million Barrels Per Day

  • Japan to reimport nuclear fuel from France: source
  • SKorea announces 28.5 bln dollar energy plan
  • Areva, Mitsubishi announce nuclear fuel tie-up
  • US Bechtel wins Egypt nuclear power contract

  • Greenhouse gas emissions study released
  • Research Into Fair-Weather Clouds Important In Climate Predictions
  • ESA Tests Laser To Measure Atmospheric Carbon Dioxide
  • Asia not responsible for 'brown haze': India

  • Real Christmas trees 'greener' than fakes
  • Ghana's 'miracle': logging underwater forests for exotic timber
  • Climate change putting forests at risk
  • Thwarting Efforts To Use Carbon Markets To Halt Deforestation

  • Former dairy boss tried over China tainted milk scandal
  • Two more stand trial in China milk scandal
  • Chinese dairy firms to pay out millions to milk victims: state media
  • Taiwan home-grown food firms get boost after China scandal

  • China's Foton says clean energy car factory opened in Beijing
  • Thompson Files: Wisdom on the bailout
  • China plans to avert US-style auto crisis: report
  • China opens road tunnel under Yangtze: state media

  • China Eastern says bailout increased to one billion dollars
  • Britain's environment minister concerned by Heathrow plan
  • Climate protesters cause chaos at British airport
  • Thompson Files: Protect U.S. aerospace

  • Nuclear Power In Space - Part 2
  • Outside View: Nuclear future in space
  • Nuclear Power In Space

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement